I suppose the OP could confirm if the tech on the repair task actually climbed the pole or not (and confirm it is indeed overhead service ) if the tech never climbed , it was probably laziness or a misunderstanding , especially if the customer indicated this was tied up with a separate FTTP migration at the same address , so the tech assumed the customer would explore an IP telephony solution on the broadband service that exists.
As stated it’s still a UW problem to get OR to return , and TBH , the fault report , even if incorrectly closed by the tech should still exist , a robotic test of the line should indicate the line is still disconnected ( no socket detected on the line ) which results in the report being resurrected, but I wouldn’t rely on that and contact UW again, and at the next visit insist on the wire being replaced.
On the off chance the tech did actually climb the pole , and suggested the way to proceed was because this UW ‘line’ wasn’t actually available at the pole top , may suggest this isn’t just a case of replacing a missing dropwire otherwise they would have done that , but my suspicion is that they didn’t climb .
I suspect what happened is the Installer has used the existing Copper Drop Cable that was either a DW11b (2 Pair) or DW15 (4 Pair) to cut and draw the new Fibre Cable.
Probably didn’t realise there was a second line.
What confuses me though is why the Engineer who attended the Repair visit claimed he couldn’t fix it?!?!
Was he also from Kelly’s and or MJ Quinn’s?
Openreach are getting worse and worse.
No wonder so many CP’s are now jumping ship to Alt Nets where possible.